• Recent Posts

  • Categories

  • Archives

  • Meta

Crockpot: Soda and Onion Soup Mix Beef Roast

beef, crockpot

Cruising the meat aisle on Sunday when I did my shopping, I brought home a beef roast. Can’t remember the exact cut. It was boneless. It was also tied with strings, which I cut off given that I was going to slow cooker it. I’d been wanting to try some variation of the soda-onion soup-crockpot roast I’d seen rave reviews of on various cooking lists to which I subscribe.

I almost gave in this morning for a sure thing roast. I had a can of cranberry jelly in the pantry and the tried and true cranberry pot roast recipe was calling strongly. But, as I often do, I resisted and held out for the new and untried recipe. It is super simple. It is, as I’d read, very very good.

1 beef roast
1 envelope onion soup mix
1 can cream of mushroom soup
1 can of soda

Put it all in your slow cooker. If you have an older one that doesn’t spit and bubble even on low, I’d cook it it on low 8-10 hours hours or high 4-6 hours. If you have a newer model, like mine, that boils (not just simmers!) even on low, allow about 5 hours on low and don’t even think about cooking it on high. Really, you just need to get to know your own slow cooker and follow their guidelines. There is a huge difference between newer and older models.

I’ve seen variations of this recipe with and without the “cream of” soup, one with a packet of brown gravy mix, one with fresh mushrooms, and one with a packet of Italian dressing mix and a beer instead of the soda!

This produced a nice au jus that was a bit thicker than you’d get without the “cream of” soup but not as thick as a gravy. If you want a gravy, take out the roast and stir in some flour and water (2 Tbs flour mixed with 3 Tbs cup cold water) and let it simmer a bit while you do the rest of dinner prep.

I served it with rice and cooked carrots and it was a huge hit.

Share/Save/Bookmark

No Comments

No Responses

  1. Ian McKenzie  •  January 11, 2006 @5:39 am

    That sounds pretty good. Can you clarify what you mean by soda? Up here in Canada, soda is carbonated water, whereas I believe Americans have a different definition for soda. Thanks,

  2. Ellen  •  January 13, 2006 @5:21 am

    Yes, soda here means sweetened carbonated water, so 7-up, Sprite, Coca Cola, or even Ginger Ale are what I’ve seen mentioned. What do you guys call those? In different parts of the US it might be called pop, soda, co-cola, soda pop, coke (even when not referring to Coca Cola), and probably many more names I don’t know!

  3. vanessa  •  January 15, 2006 @4:21 am

    though i don’t really drink it, i have a soft-spot for recipes that use soda. my mom used to cook ham in coca-cola. the best glaze ever. but once she made these cold buckwheat noodles we always have in the summer and for fun, put 7-Up into the cold “soup” instead of hte vinegar/broth mixture. It was really good :) Your recipe sounds fun!

  4. FishMama  •  January 19, 2006 @2:13 pm

    Does this make it sweet? I’ve always wanted to try this, but my husband doesn’t care for sweet main dishes (no ketchup, no sweet and sour, etc.)

  5. Mary  •  January 26, 2006 @2:20 am

    I just made this dish over the weekend, but without the soda. It came out quite lovely. After the roast was done (2.5 lbs for 8 hours), I took the gravy from the bottom and simmered it in a pot with whole canned potatoes that were on sale this week. It was very good.

  6. Anonymous  •  August 25, 2007 @1:28 am

    I give this recipe a ten stars..my family loved it…We did not have coke or sprite so I used pepsi which was great with dried onions and seasoning instad of onion mixed. My son said, THIS IS SUPER!!!

Tell me what you think

Allowed tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>